Mary Willingham's Response to UNC’s Independent Evaluation of Research Posted Apr 16, 2014 To avoid technical discussion and to get right to the heart of the matter, I will simply say that the three outside experts who conducted the “independent” review of my data did not come close to replicating my analysis. They were unable to do so because they were denied access to the full range of test scores that formed the basis of my critical judgment. (PaperClassInc.com)