| # | Name | Awards |
| | Cartwright Carmichael 1921-1924 | First-team All-America |
| 00 | Eric Montross 1990-1994 | Second-team All-America |
| 00 | Brendan Haywood 1997–2001 | Second-team All-America |
| 2 | Raymond Felton 2002-2005 | MVP of NCAA Champions |
| 2 | Joel Berry 2014-2018 | NCAA Tournament MOP |
| 4 | R.J. Davis 2020-2024 | ACC Player of the Year |
| 5 | Ty Lawson 2006-2009 | Second-team All-America, ACC Player of the Year, MVP of NCAA Champions |
| 5 | Marcus Paige 2012-2016 | First-team All-America |
| 8 | Jim Jordan 1944-1946 | Second-team All-America |
| 11 | Larry Brown 1960-1963 | Olympic gold medal |
| 11 | Brice Johnson 2012-2016 | First-team All-America |
| 12 | Lee Shaffer 1957-1960 | First-team All-America, ACC Player of the Year |
| 13 | John Dillon 1945-1948 | First-team All-America |
| 15 | Vince Carter 1995-1998 | Second-team All-America, Olympic gold medal |
| 21 | Mitch Kupchak 1972-1976 | First-team All-America, ACC Player of the Year, Olympic gold medal |
| 21 | Donald Williams 1991-1995 | NCAA Tournament MOP |
| 22 | York Larese 1958-1961 | Second-team All-America |
| 22 | Bob Lewis 1964-1967 | First-team All-America |
| 22 | Wayne Ellington 2006-2009 | NCAA Tournament MOP |
| 24 | Walter Davis 1973-1977 | Olympic gold medal |
| 30 | Al Wood 1977-1981 | First-team All-America |
| 30 | Kenny Smith 1983-1987 | First-team All-America |
| 30 | Rasheed Wallace 1993-1995 | Second-team All-America |
| 31 | Bill Chamberlain 1969-1972 | Second-team All-America |
| 31 | Mike O'Koren 1976-1980 | First-team All-America |
| 32 | Billy Cunningham 1962-1965 | First-team All-America, ACC Player of the Year |
| 32 | Rashad McCants 2002-2005 | Second-team All-America |
| 33 | Charlie Scott 1967-1970 | Olympic gold medal, First-team All-America |
| 34 | Bobby Jones 1971-1974 | First-team All-America |
| 34 | J.R. Reid 1986-1989 | First-team All-America |
| 34 | George Lynch 1989-1993 | MVP of NCAA Champions |
| 35 | Pete Brennan 1955-1958 | First-team All-America, ACC Player of the Year |
| 35 | Doug Moe 1958-1961 | First-team All-America |
| 35 | Bob McAdoo 1971-1972 | First-team All-America |
| 40 | Tommy Kearns 1955-1958 | Second-team All-America |
| 40 | Joseph Forte 1999–2001 | First-team All-America, ACC Player of the Year |
| 40 | Harrison Barnes 2010-2012 | Second-team All-America, Olympic Gold Medal |
| 41 | Sam Perkins 1980-1984 | Olympic gold medal, First-team All-America |
| 42 | Brad Daugherty 1982-1986 | First-team All-America |
| 42 | Jerry Stackhouse 1993-1995 | First-team All-America |
| 42 | Sean May 2002-2005 | First-team All-America, MVP of NCAA Champions, NCAA Tournament MOP |
| 44 | Larry Miller 1965-1968 | First-team All-America, ACC Player of the Year |
| 44 | Dennis Wuycik 1969-1972 | First-team All-America |
| 44 | Tyler Zeller 2008-2012 | Second-team All-America, ACC Player of the Year |
| 44 | Justin Jackson 2014-2017 | First Team All-America, ACC Player of the Year, MVP of NCAA Champions |
| 45 | Tommy LaGarde 1973-1977 | Olympic gold medal, Second-team All-America |